An Orthographic Appendix

 
 
 
 
The notion that pre-modern Chinese primarily used traditional ideographs has no factual basis.

Many of the so-called simplified ideographs are in fact traditional forms. They were stylistic variants used in informal registers. Not infrequently, the simplified variant was the only attested form of an ideograph in the informal genres.

Fast forward to present-day Mandarin, it has proven futile to imagine that a single character set could prevail in any given population. Even within established ‘simplified’ regions, ‘traditional’ character sets are freely used in everyday communications as an aesthetic or political choice. With the arrival of personal computing, the ability to decode is all it requires to be able to encode with ease.

Today, the task of the lexicographer is simply to document which style each variant of an ideograph came from.

***

In the table that follows, k’ai forms are those commonly used during the Chin–T’ang period; ts’ao, hsing and print forms are annotated with the period in which they are first attested. Use git blame to see the sources for such attestation.

Only forms that are still current in everyday usage tend to be included.

If all current variants of an ideograph already existed in k’ai, no other styles are exemplified. If a variant existed in ts’ao, it is not further exemplified from hsing. Being the cursive of k’ai, hsing is in general later than ts’ao, which was originally the cursive of li.

The etymology of an ideograph is only touched on insofar as such knowledge motivated the use of an archaising glyph in k’ai. Usage statement of dictionaries is cited as secondary evidence.

Bibliography

Theory

Sources

For studies of the variants in incunabulas, see Variant Ideographs in Incunabula.

 

K’aiTs’aoHsingPrintNote
/爱 Sui爱 Ming 
//罢 Ch’ing 
//摆 Ch’ing 
幫 Sung//帮 Ch’ing幫 attested in 廣韻
綁 Ming//绑 Ming綁 attested in 字彙
/报 T’ang报 Sung 
///贝 in Huang Hsiang & imitators & once in Ch’ing print
備 俻//备 Ch’ing 
筆 笔//笔 Yüan笔 also in 集韻 as variant
//边 Yüan 
标 T’ang// 
別 别///别 is stylistic variant
并 並 竝///竝 is archaism; in most Tunhuang sources, 并 is Prep & 並 V/Adv
/// 
/佈 Ming/佈 already in 廣韻
采 採/// 
/// 
长 Han/长 Yüan 
廠 Sung///attested in 廣韻
//鈔 Ming鈔 already in 廣韻 as variant; cf. Tseng–Ch’en (2018), 6
车 Han// 
///尘 in 字彙補; not attested at Tunhuang
/痴 Ming痴 Ch’ing 
//担 Yüan 
//单 Yüan 
///cf. 彈 (t’an)
///遞 in 廣韻 is archaism; 递 in 宋本玉篇
/点 Ming/ 
//垫 Ch’ing 
/// 
东 Han/东 Ch’ing 
/// 
///‘闘鬬 中通下正’ (干祿字書); 鬬 not attested at Tunhuang
鍍 Sung///attested in 廣韻
发 Chin// 
/// 
泛 汎/// 
///飰 Sung print
费 Han/费 Ch’ing 
废 T’ang// 
///cf. 鳳
//风 Ming 凤 Ch’ing风 commonly confused with 風
/// 
///桿 in 元刋四聲篇海
構 搆/// 
骨 (TW) Ming骨 (CN) T’ang//骨 (TW), attested in 字彙, is archaism
///広 1891 kanji
//国 Ch’ing国 1133 kanji; 囯 Sung print
//过 Yüan 
/后 Chin后 Yüan 
/画 Ming画 Ch’ing畵 > 画 is late archaism
迴 廻 回/// 
会 Han/会 Ming 
匯 彙/// 
///卽 in 廣韻 is archaism
/// 
记 Han/记 Ch’ing 
迹 跡 蹟/// 
夹 夾///夾 is later archaism
//艰 Ming 
減 减/// 
检 Wu// 
/// 
脚 腳///腳 in 說文 & rare
/觧 Chin觧 Yüan 
/// 
//据 Ch’ing 
/隽 Chin/從人 in MSS
觉 T’ang/觉 Ch’ing 
/// 
刊 刋///刋 is stylistic variant
克 剋/// 
况 況///況 is archaism
礦 鑛///鉱 1889 kanji
来 來///來 is later archaism
乐 Han/乐 Ch’ing 
/// 
/// 
马 Wu/马 YüanUnicode 马 has wrong stroke order
脉 脈///‘脈脉 上說文下經典相承’ (五經文字)
/// 
貿贸 T’ang//cf. 貝
//难 Ming 
惱 Sung//恼 Ch’ing惱 attested in 廣韻
腦 Sung//脑 Ch’ing腦 attested in 廣韻
/// 
/// 
///cf. 攝 躡
//蹑 Ming 
砲 Sung//炮 Ch’ing 
/评 Ming/ 
/齐 T’ang齐 Ming 
//骑 Yüan 
氣 气///气 in 說文 & rare
棄 弃/// 
/// 
/// 
潛 潜//潜 Ming 
/// 
/// 
牆 墻/墙 Sung墙 Sung 
//权 Ming 
却 卻///卻 is archaism
羣 群/// 
繞 遶/绕 Ming/ 
/热 Ming热 Yüan 
/闰 T’ang/ 
//杀 Yüan‘杀古殺字’ (五經文字)
///伤 in Miao’s forgery
//摄 Ming 
//寿 Yüan寿 Sung hsing?
//书 Ch’ing 
/// 
/诉 Sung诉 Ch’ing 
//虽 Yüan 
孙 Han/孙 Ming 
//台 Yüan 
/// 
//弹 Ming 
//体 Yüan体 also in 字鑑
///鉄 Yüan print & kanji
万 萬/// 
為 爲为 Han/为 Yüan爲 is later archaism
///cf. 違
违 Chin/违 Ch’ing 
無 无/// 
/// 
峡 峽///cf. 夹
/险 T’ang/ 
/// 
///e.g. 歐陽脩
///cf. 脩
/许 Chin/ 
/// 
学 Wu// 
//仪 Yüan 
//义 Yüan 
应 T’ang/应 Ch’ing応 1753 kanji; Wang Hsi-chih’s 应 in Li is fake
//营 Yüan 
///湧 attested in 集韻
踊 踴///踴 attested in 集韻
與 与/// 
/语 Chin语 Ch’ing 
云 雲/// 
张 Han// 
真 眞///眞 is archaism
/郑 T’ang郑 Ch’ing 
/证 Ch’in证 Ch’ing 
誌 Sung/// 
//制 Ming 
//质 Ch’ing 
/// 
/众 Ming众 Ch’ing众 already in 龍龕手鏡人部 (玉篇 has a different glyph); 眾 is archaism
豬 猪//猪 Ming 
庄 T’ang/庄 Ming